Thursday, March 24, 2016

James Clapper, James Comey (FBI) & John Brennan (CIA) Ya'll Know Sotheby's Real Estate Division Was Started in 1976 to Launder Money During the DIRTY WAR & to Help Nazi's & Their Families the CIA Was Protecting & It's Getting DeClassified..... Thank You Jesus!!!! Anyway I'm Alleging Sotheby's Conspired with My Aunt Who Dated a Child of a Nazi War Criminal Who in the 70's my Grandfather & the CIA Tried to Make the President of Argentina CONSPIRED to Destroy My Mom's Estate Leaving Me with No Way to Pay for the High Cost of Obamacare Premiums - I'd Like the Justice Department to Do a FULL Investigation ....


Obama announced yesterday their declassifying all the “dirty war” stuff…. evidently people “the CLUB” played a big role & iWas told ALL the abuse done to me by members of my own family was one of the factors used to get the approval for the declassification … I represent "just one" of the people that had the courage to say “hey this isn’t morally right” & tragically I was bullied by members of my own family (Cathy) slandered me. The declassification is happening much earlier than people expected or wanted.


Sotheby’s International Realty is a luxury real estate brand founded in 1976 by the Sotheby's Auction House. Sotheby's International Realty operates as a franchise focusing on brokering and marketing of luxury residential real estate.

 ".... First, the issue of our relationship or friendship:  Although we have known each other since the 1960’s, we had not seen nor communicated with each other for decades.  The fact that you knew me and my family, I believe, for you and your sister, Claudia, gave you a sense of relief because you accurately trusted that I would have  your family’s best interest at heart, which of course I did.  From my end, I wanted to do my best work for you and your family because of my respect for you and Claudia....."  Villa Kakis Gilles (my mom's realtor who sent my aunt a snarky email to forward to me AFTER i questioned her judgement on selling my mom's house I believe she's loyal to CIA/MIC cligue linked to Leon Panett, Hillary Clinton & Tony Blair & was once the John McCone. This clique did the dirty work for the dirty wars of Henry Kissinger) 

Nazi-looted painting sells for £1.9 million at Sotheby's ...

www.telegraph.co.uk › Culture › Art › Art News
The Daily Telegraph
Jun 25, 2015 - Max Liebermann's Two Riders on a Beach - one of the more than 1,200 works of art found in the Munich apartment of German recluse Cornelius Gurlitt – smashes expectations at London sale. ... Max Liebermann's "Two Riders on a Beach" was found among more than 1,200 works of art in the ...

Nazi-looted painting fetches astonishing price at Sotheby′s ...

www.dw.com/en/nazi-looted-painting-fetches...sothebys/a-18539873

Jun 25, 2015 - It had been looted by the Nazis, hidden for decades, and then discovered in a dramatic art raid. Now Max Liebermann's famous "Two Riders on ...

Sotheby's and Christie's Split on Response to Nazi Victim's Art

https://news.artnet.com/art.../sothebys-and-christies-split-on-response-to-...

Oct 27, 2014 - Christie's and Sotheby's respective handling of two Egon Schiele artworks once owned by Fritz Grünbaum, a German cabaret performer who ...


Easter must be coming….out of the blue my sister got a job interview & it’s in a place that she loves & “that" will help put her back on track…. to the person organizing that THANK YOU!!!!

Also i was reminded that the last time i “proved” my Aunt Cathy had treated me poorly by wanting to use my mom’s Marriott timeshare & take her husband to Hawaii … (she’s the executor/conservator of the estate & not listed as an estate heir) & I had asked to use the same time share & was told a “variety” of answers & then I told mom’s lawyer Kyle Krasa & then Cathy called me VERY MAD & said she’d not use the time share but has allowed nobody to use it &  I recently learned she almost let get foreclosed upon- I bet if she & dave were going on trips to Hawaii she wouldve paid the bills?  Basically she  refused to give it to me (even when i requested it as part of an inheritance - i explained it was so I could take my child on a yearly summer trip that would be known as a “ gift” from her grandmother, one she only met a few times because the CIA had a con man marry my mom & put a wedge between us) & Cathy for 2 years has played games with it.  

Anyway after I proved Cathy was maliciously snubbing me w/ the timeshare request i got a spur of the moment 2 week cruise & god flew me business class:):)   

I’m tired and cranky & need another vacation so In hopes that god is listening Cathy hasn’t changed … she’s still mean to me & YES it’s obvious she's harmed the value of mom’s estate, worse I hear she rarely visits my mom & refuses to let mom’s caregivers talk to me about her health.  Cathy is micro-managing mom & I believe doing a lousy job on purpose.  All I can do is be silent & let my mom die. It’s heartbreaking.  Anyway I was just reminded that I can’t let her actions hurt me & that means I can’t let the hate I have for her neglecting mom & her ignoring my request for access to money to take my child on vacations this summer (I’m in the middle of a divorce & not allowed to spend money frivolously). 

YES i know I can’t let petty issues over money change me. Mom always said that 'I was the child the never asked for money & she adjusted her will because she knew I’d be a good steward of the resources I received' (just ask Kyle Krasa)…. All my life i’ve supported myself & I’m not a greedy person. (I'm only writing this cause my family has slandered me for 6 years.... they hate me cause i blogged the truth)

My Aunts have said things about me that are NOT TRUE.. Cathy without my permission contacted my minor child and told her things about me. She not only keeps me away from my mom but she has hurt my current relationship with my child.  I’ve been warned that my Aunts have slandered me , they do it out of fear.  They want our families legacy to be one of good things.  Yes I blogged that our family protected Nazi’s & that my Aunt had a relationship with a man the CIA was helping as part of the American governments Nazi Protection~ South American Dictator recruitment program … i blogged the truth. I blogged cause I was scared, I was poisoned, jailed, had two mysterious car accidents & I live in a constant state of fear.  My mom told me “don’t trust anyone… you have a target on your back”… 

I’m a person that was raised CIA but my DNA could be that of a man that the CIA played a role in whacking his brother.  Papa told me in reference to the “ JFK deal” the cover-up was worse than the crime.  I never understood what he said, the crime included the murder of an American president.  NOW i get it (maybe)  I think the CIA played a role in the cover-up but not the murder & in the cover-up the CIA played a role in whacking the brother of the dead president, which would be worse than being involved with “just” the cover-up of the dead president.  I was raised by the people who did the JKF cover-up which itself is not easy to live with…. now put yourself in my shoes … I’ve been told that people think my bio dad is the brother of the whacked president. That means my family whacked my family, one that won’t be confirmed or denied.  I live with a lot of unknowns.  I know the people that raised me were not there for me when I needed help.  They knew i was bullied in TN because of my CIA past, I was involved with the CIA not out of my own free will but because I was born into the CIA.  My conception might’ve been part of a CIA cover-up.  My CIA family ditched me cause I make them feel uncomfortable.  The Gammons that were our closest family friends “ditched” me. 

Yet even after being alienated by my known family & their closest friends good things happen to me. I got that cruise last year maybe something good will happen this year? who knows….  All I know is god exists & I know I’m gonna be OK.  I know that I told the truth. I know helping people is in my DNA (then I googled my other bio dad possibility Ed Daly… he had a generous spirit & was a bit of a bull in China shop (kind like me) when it came to insisting on RESPECT for ALL People.  Maybe it’s people connected to him that have helped me?  I do not know & I’ve accepted I will never know.  

This weekend i just have to figure out how to accept that my Aunt has an agenda to harm me & i can’t change that.  I told my mom’s estate lawyer Kyle Krasa & if he’s a decent human being he’ll stop Cathy form hurting mom, Heather & I.   Sadly I know Cathy will never change on her own.. cause it’s in her DNA …. she’s gonna protect the CIA that helped the Nazi’s cause that’s what her family does…it’s ingrained in her to disrespect anyone “not in the club” … Yes I’m a member of her family  BUT I’m wired differently I got some compassionate-justice seeking DNA that has respect for all people in me that has overshadowed the evil CIA DNA.  I will always be a person that believes the best in ALL people & a person that has hope for a better tomorrow. 

Happy Easter

Sharyn 




Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: fyi 
Date: March 22, 2016 at 12:42:39 AM EDT
To: viliaonbch@aol.com

...

I’m gonna be working on IRANContraSpy.com tomorrow I’m really upset Kyle & Cathy believe Sultana was “ethical” OMG her family got a ton of $$$ from the US government for their land in Kurdistan as a “kickback”…..  just another MIC/CIA dirty deal…. which some people think are OK.  the fact is America is morally corrupt because of people from the Monterey Peninsula Country Club that are part of the clique that my Aunt Cathy respects MORE than members of her own family.  http://senatordiannefeinstein.blogspot.com/2016/02/oddly-my-uncle-got-dementia-too-after-i.html





\



Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: Forgot the BEST Update Dirty War Declassification Announced TODAY 
Date: March 22, 2016 at 9:54:40 PM EDT
To: viliaonbch@aol.com, jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com>, "Kyle A. Krasa" <kyle@krasalaw.com>

Obama announced TODAY their declassifying all the “dirty war” stuff…. evidently people “the CLUB” played a big role & iWas told ALL the abuse done to me by members of my own family was one of the factors used to get the approval for the declassification … I represent "just one" of the people that had the courage to say “hey this isn’t morally right” & tragically I was bullied- members of my own family (Cathy) slandered me.  The declassification is happening much earlier than people expected or wanted.  It’s possible calls for Henry Kissinger to be tried for WAR CRIMES could happen. Oh Well….…. so all the shit I’ve lived with ya’ll  get to hear about in the news and people can say… wasn’t your dad part of that?  

 I’m a person and dammit I deserve RESPECT!!!!  Cathy abused me cause she was scared of the truth…. & now the truth is gonna be her legacy & it’s called KARMA
:):) Sharyn 


Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: i'm done obsessing about Vilia the Nazi Protecting CIA connected realtor.... sounds like a great chapter for a book:):) 
Date: March 22, 2016 at 1:51:25 PM EDT
To: jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com>, viliaonbch@aol.com

Well ladies …. I’ve gotta “move on” & focus on my presentation for next week (I’m going to a human rights conference in the Silicon Valley... meeting with a bunch of digital human rights activist) & i have a project to work on for my toastmasters club. I’m having to learn how to do public speaking cause I was told that I’m gonna be asked to to a Ted Talk.

So Vilia my ranting about you is over unless ppl reach out to me with relevant data. Anyway I always have time for clarifications so call me 615-944-7599 if what I blogged about needs clarity, I always give people the opportunity to clarify.  

Respect is Earned! 

Sharyn
iGot over 5 million Google+ views:):) 



"RESPECT is a word used by a LOT of people connected to Leon Panetta  in Pebble Beach .."  Sharyn Bovat the DOD Whistleblower   

I had heard Panetta wanted mom OUT of Pebble Beach cause he didn't want me wandering around Monterey. 




\




I believe my Aunt has bullied me since she took over the management of my mom's estate because I blogged that she dated the son of a Nazi War Criminal from Argentina in the 70's and my grandma told me that Papa was gonna make him President.  Papa was part of OPERATION CONDOR. Because i blogged the truth (only AFTER NISSAN outed me for being a former CIA researcher) about ppl that belong to the Monterey Peninsula Country Club I've been terrorized by people connected to a CIA/MIC clique that became strong AFTER the assassination of JFK.  

  ".... First, the issue of our relationship or friendship:  Although we have known each other since the 1960’s, we had not seen nor communicated with each other for decades.  The fact that you knew me and my family, I believe, for you and your sister, Claudia, gave you a sense of relief because you accurately trusted that I would have  your family’s best interest at heart, which of course I did.  From my end, I wanted to do my best work for you and your family because of my respect for you and Claudia....."  Villa Kakis Gilles (my mom's realtor who sent my aunt a snarky email to forward to me AFTER i questioned her judgement on selling my mom's house I believe she's loyal to CIA/MIC cligue linked to Leon Panett, Hillary Clinton & Tony Blair & was once the John McCone. This clique did the dirty work for the dirty wars of Henry Kissinger) 

 Please NOTE she has 3 generations of ties to the Pebble Beach/Monterey Peninsula community that is politically controlled by Leon Panetta JUST like my mom's (now my Aunt Cathy's) attorney Kyle Krasa. There's a CIA/MIC clique that John McCone created, the 2nd & 3rd generation have succeeded in life because they are LOYAL "go along to get along" types. 

Begin forwarded message:
Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: I tried calling you back 
Date: March 22, 2016 at 10:21:26 AM EDT
To: h_bov@hotmail.com

Heather,

Looks like there's  more to the realtor story... She's protecting the CIA clique that's part of the county club.  Villia is just like Kyle Krasa she's been on PB since 60's and has a "connected family" she probably convinced Cathy to move you out of California ... I'm sorry you feel abandon in Alaska.  Just stay SAFE.

Nothing makes sense but ppl wanted a fast sale and for you & I to not be wandering around the Pebble Beach area ... Take care of your self.

Ted Stevens ghost is haunting them right now... New laws are being created in his honor.

We have to deal with Cathy cause no matter how she does her job Kyle will keep her- just like he kept the Iraqi caregiver who profited when the US govt bought her families land in Kurdistan.

Bottom-line : The ppl that are managing mom right now are basically disciples of a CIA/MIC clique linked to Dick Cheney - mega corporations, Leon Panetta, Hillary Clinton & Tony Blair.  Just be nice to them and beg for a disability check.

All I want is for them to give me affordable health insurance and for Cathy to stop limiting my contact with moms caregivers. What's going on right no to me is beyond cruel. The wedge they put between me & mom can only be described as inhumane. You call me if you want to speak .. I just wanted to let you know I tried to return your call but never got through.


Sharyn 
Sent from my iPhone

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: fyi 
Date: March 22, 2016 at 12:42:39 AM EDT
To: viliaonbch@aol.com

I’m gonna be working on IRANContraSpy.com tomorrow I’m really upset Kyle & Cathy believe Sultana was “ethical” OMG her family got a ton of $$$ from the US government for their land in Kurdistan as a “kickback”…..  just another MIC/CIA dirty deal…. which some people think are OK.  the fact is America is morally corrupt because of people from the Monterey Peninsula Country Club that are part of the clique that my Aunt Cathy respects MORE than members of her own family.  http://senatordiannefeinstein.blogspot.com/2016/02/oddly-my-uncle-got-dementia-too-after-i.html

Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: I never would have posted the phone conversation had you NOT ASKED ME To Apologize on the Internet 
Date: March 16, 2016 at 12:29:39 PM EDT
To: jogthru@yahoo.com

Cathy,

You know I'm a blogger who has a history of airing issues on the web (going forward tell me at beginning of conversation to keep it QT, & I will).

You clearly told me to put my apology on the Internet.  You can't play victim when you wanted it public --- you asked me to make it public. If you don't like what I made public I can put the entire 40 minute phone conversation on the Internet... I have no problem doing that if it would make you happy.

I really thought you'd be happy about the clip I posted because it clearly shows I was wrong & I made it public that I was wrong about my allegation of you harming mom & I think "that's" indeed what you wanted on the Internet.  Do I need to keep fighting you virally or can you give me access to information about my moms health?

Thank you

Sharyn

Sent from my iPhone

So my 1/2 sister contacted me about her concerns of mom's estate being mis-managed. I defended my Aunt Cathy but out of respect for my sister I did a google search of my mom's house & what she told me seemed like it could be a real & serious concern. 


This is the letter that started the dialogue with Vilia the Pebble Beach realtor..... 



Begin forwarded message:



Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: Everyone Can Clearly Tell THIS Problem is REAL ... It's one that's NOT Classified Too 
Date: March 20, 2016 at 5:29:26 PM EDT
To: jogthru@yahoo.com, kyle@krasalaw.com, Michael Dorris <michael.dorris@credit-suisse.com>, Michael Reyes <mike_reyes@outlook.com>, Jim Gammon <pboceanview@sbcglobal.net>, h_bov@hotmail.com, Claudia <cojocar1@telus.net>, daniepm5@ucia.gov

Hello,
Cathy sold Moms house for 900k and it was then quickly flipped for 1,100,000.  Heather had alleged Cathy gave her friend a full 6% commission who brought in a buyer & it was NEVER on MLS ... Cathy refused to market the home allowing for other offers.

Today I talked to a lawyer friend &.was told to pull the emails I sent to Krasa & Cathy  "warning" of this PRIOR to the sale of moms house & to send it to the DA of Monterey County if I believe collusion was involved.  This type of scam hurts a LOT of ppl and why anyone (Kyle Krasa) didn't question the quick-cheap sale of moms home is sad. I think both Heather & I deserve and explanation & "if" the realtor was a friend of Cathy's then Cathy should immediately quit her role in managing moms estate. I'd like to see an accounting & "this" proves one needs to be provided.

***The realtor needs to be investigative as to their role if Cathy was unaware. HELLO It's slightly obvious moms house was "given away"... Even after all the hard work.


After finding this out I feel like Cathy fiscally raped me she is NOT to be trusted with moms estate & NOBODY is stopping her from abusing me (sad emoji)

Is it cause the CIA want to hurt me ... Seriously Dan Meyer is this how the CIA protects ppl that protected America?

Please STOP hurting me ... Obamacare is not cheap and I need moms estate managed responsibly.

Sharyn Bovat 


From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Date: March 21, 2016 at 11:13:07 PM EDT
To: viliaonbch@aol.com
Cc: jogthru@yahoo.com


If you google Bankers Trust Scandal my pic pops 1st and also Google Nancy Reagan Spy - it's ME!!


I'm dyslexic but have a high IQ and I HATE condescending ppl...  My aunt keeps thinking she can "one up me" but she can't and if she keeps trying to bully me or embarrass me it's gonna bite her in the butt .. All I care about is having access to HOW MY MOTHER Is and I want Cathy to give the hospice the ok for them to talk to me cause i have NO RESPECT for Cathy (right now) cause she's all about protecting her ass and it seems she has little respect for my mom or her estate.
Cathy was more concerned about proving to be correct than addressing the issues... It's just sad.

Cathy must have felt awesome when you sent her that articulate wordy email.. Yet a woman who claims to be a minister has no clue what motivates me.

If Cathy has an ounce of humanity she'll let me have access to moms caregivers cause I sure as hell don't trust her... I LOVE my mom!!!!

Cathy Trust is earned & I get she doesn't trust me cause I blog BUT I blog to stay alive ... I got people trying to discredit me ...& they've tried to hurt me too. Cathy knows it's real but when I was in need of family Cathy looked the other way.  She's a "go along to get along type" she's  like you.

"....  As a top producing agent both locally and nationally, a Stanford graduate and a long time local who has been selling real estate in this community for over 32 years,  my credentials substantiate the fact that I always give 100% to my clients in translating their needs and getting the job done..."  Villa Kakis Gilles 

Lastly I have no disrespect for grads of fancy schools but I hate ppl that rub their degrees in the face of ppl.  A degree from Stanford tells me nothing about a persons character all it tells me is thy have "connections" & if you ever belittle or slander me or say (as you insinuated I your email) that I care about money & not my mom ... If you ever do that I will be pissed so upset you could call it sorrysilverman.com upset.

I hope this rant is taken w/humor & a bit of reality & that's you entered a family food fight... The Frisbie family is dysfunctional family yet were strong family & I'd like you to not insult me to her cause I believe in my heart one day she'll wake up & realize I'm a force of good.  Sure it's been messy BUT the world will be better because I had the courage to confront truth to power.   I got my courage from my MOM whose the reason WHY I'm so upset today.

Have a great night!?!
          Sharyn 



Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: I know Moms realtor Leon Panetta CIA connected 
Date: March 21, 2016 at 10:34:45 PM EDT
To: jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com>, viliaonbch@aol.com, daniepm5@ucia.gov, Michael Dorris <michael.dorris@credit-suisse.com>, kyle@krasalaw.com, Michael Reyes <mike_reyes@outlook.com>, Jim Gammon <pboceanview@sbcglobal.net>, dcharney@roundhousecenter.com, Claudia <cojocar1@telus.net>, h_bov@hotmail.com

Hello All

FYI -I got an ALL cash offer on my home in TN after I had a death threat ... The buyer a celebrity that was on Dancing with the Stars ... He got an appearance fee at the Concourse De Elegance that was = to the cost of my house ... He let his sister have the house & she was upset her celebrity brother bought her a home with 3 bedrooms when she had 3 kids. 

Anyway  I later learned it was a gift from Leon Panetta's ppl ... We were asking 369 and they offered all cash quick close 370.  I never really thought (mom's sale)... was a horrible deal I thought it was a CIA deal (Heather thought it was horrible & I will say if Villia knew the market so well she might've told you to wait? )  I had heard Panetta wanted mom OUT of Pebble Beach cause he didn't want me wandering around Monterey. 

I'm not about money Im about MORALITY something that is lacking in my family.  

sometimes to get the truth you have to hear "how it happened"...  I sure wish the CIA would help Heather get disability since they were part of whacking her Ted Stevens (who Heather worked for) & I wish the CIA helped me get health insurance.  Dan Meyer is Villia still gonna be a "preferred provider"?

Cathy ... Just be HONEST & don't fuck with me cause I got smart friends - who might be part of the New New World Order.

Villia read about me sharynBovat.com 

It's about HUMANITY bitch the days of CIA dirty deals are almost done ... Hope the connected realtor has a sense of humor... (kiss emoji) 
Sharyn 


Begin forwarded message: 

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: Re: Records Show "Fishy" Transaction in reference to sale of Mom's Home. Estate can re-coup loss via action against realtor. It Starts with a formal complaint to the Real Estate Board .
Date: March 21, 2016 at 10:12:02 PM EDT
To: jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com>, viliaonbch@aol.com
  " During this time, I called Heather and left a message for her.  I wanted to discuss what had transpired and I also had a question about a major repair under the house that the new owner had to do.   I had hoped she didn’t pay for that repair as it had not been done.  But she did not return my call...." Villia Kakis Gilles

Let me be CLEAR Heather is the person that told me the problem ... Had she not been so upset I never would have questioned it. (refer to email ....This makes Villia's email a JOKE since she compliments Heather profusely ... Thanks for cc'ing the entire list Cathy:)

Sent from my iPhone


Begin forwarded message:

From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Subject: Everyone Can Clearly Tell THIS Problem is REAL ... It's one that's NOT Classified Too 
Date: March 20, 2016 at 5:29:26 PM EDT
To: jogthru@yahoo.com, kyle@krasalaw.com, Michael Dorris <michael.dorris@credit-suisse.com>, Michael Reyes <mike_reyes@outlook.com>, Jim Gammon <pboceanview@sbcglobal.net>, h_bov@hotmail.com, Claudia <cojocar1@telus.net>, daniepm5@ucia.gov

Hello,
Cathy sold Moms house for 900k and it was then quickly flipped for 1,100,000.  Heather had alleged Cathy gave her friend a full 6% commission who brought in a buyer & it was NEVER on MLS ... Cathy refused to market the home allowing for other offers.

Today I talked to a lawyer friend &.was told to pull the emails I sent to Krasa & Cathy  "warning" of this PRIOR to the sale of moms house & to send it to the DA of Monterey County if I believe collusion was involved.  This type of scam hurts a LOT of ppl and why anyone (Kyle Krasa) didn't question the quick-cheap sale of moms home is sad. I think both Heather & I deserve and explanation & "if" the realtor was a friend of Cathy's then Cathy should immediately quit her role in managing moms estate. I'd like to see an accounting & "this" proves one needs to be provided.

***The realtor needs to be investigative as to their role if Cathy was unaware. HELLO It's slightly obvious moms house was "given away"... Even after all the hard work.


After finding this out I feel like Cathy fiscally raped me she is NOT to be trusted with moms estate & NOBODY is stopping her from abusing me (sad emoji)

Is it cause the CIA want to hurt me ... Seriously Dan Meyer is this how the CIA protects ppl that protected America?

Please STOP hurting me ... Obamacare is not cheap and I need moms estate managed responsibly.
Sharyn Bovat 

On Mar 21, 2016, at 10:02 PM, Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com> wrote:
   "..Buyer then did approx $3,600 worth of termite fumigation work and the tenant (executive) moved in.  Unfortunately, from the very first week, the family had trouble with the house.  The plumbing backed up three times and the plumbing/sewer line needed significant work. The garbage disposal broke.  The washing machine leaked...." Villa Kakis Gilles

Sounds like they put 10k into house & Villia writes a good "wordy" email yet fails to address the concerns... She is critical of me & Heather. it was Heather who told me about the issue and as you know I know about Real Estate. I worked for Sotheby's during the the Lockerbie Cover up- it's a CIA cover company. I'm sure your friend knows Leon Panetta's ppl:):) 

It doesn't bring me closure I believe NOW more than ever you were conned and have not been a good steward to mom's estate.  

Anyway Cathy you always have to be RIGHT it's not about the money it's about ETHICS and I hope you get my concerns answered and stop the snarky realtor can call me. 

Her email is an awesome BLOG post if she's ever screwed over anyone else I'm sure they ll contact me.  If I'm wrong about your friend "someone" will tell me (wink/smile emoji)
Have a great night (peace emoji) 

Sharyn 615-944-7599 On Mar 21, 2016, at 9:40 PM, jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com> wrote:

Sharyn,

Here is the info from Carolyn's realtor.

HI, Cathy,

     I am very sorry to hear that anyone would be anything but very pleased  with the manner in which this property was handled on behalf of your sister’s trust, starting with the Herculean effort put forth by you, Heather and the team of people you had to hire to clean out years of stuff.  That said, I would like address all of these accusations and concerns  clearly and accurately. Pardon the length of this email but there is a lot to cover.

    First, the issue of our relationship or friendship:  Although we have known each other since the 1960’s, we had not seen nor communicated with each other for decades.  The fact that you knew me and my family, I believe, for you and your sister, Claudia, gave you a sense of relief because you accurately trusted that I would have  your family’s best interest at heart, which of course I did.  From my end, I wanted to do my best work for you and your family because of my respect for you and Claudia.  

    As you recall, even then, I still met with you and your sister and interviewed for the job.  As I recall, you had spoken to at least two other agents.  As a top producing agent both locally and nationally, a Stanford graduate and a long time local who has been selling real estate in this community for over 32 years,  my credentials substantiate the fact that I always give 100% to my clients in translating their needs and getting the job done.

     Regarding the “assignment”;  as I recall, you are the trustee of your sister’s trust which, as I recall, is to benefit your sister and take care of her needs.  As I remember, the house needed to be sold in order to finance the best care possible for your sister as she needed to be in a care home.  Her needs were pressing and the goal was to get the most we could for the house in the shortest amount of time as you did not have the “luxury” of time of putting the house on the market and having it sit there for months before it sold.  As an aside,  I don’t remember her adult children’s needs as being part of the equation, as I thought the care  and comfort of your sister was what her money was to be used for.

      So, in April 2015, we met and reviewed comparable sales information as well as what was currently on the market, what size the homes were and how long they were on the market for before they sold.  Based on the statistics, we agreed that the list   price for the house  would be  $900,000, provided the house was cleaned and painted and the carpets replaced, and that this seemed to be the “sweet spot” for getting the house sold quickly.  At the time , I provided the listing paperwork as well as  the comparable sales information to you and to your trust attorney, who reviewed everything before you signed it.   The commission amount was 6%, which is the industry standard.

      Please take a look again at the comparable properties on the attached sheet, which I provided you in April as we discussed pricing.  As you can see from this report, we looked at 5 properties in the Country Club gate area of Pebble that had sold in the previous few months. Of the four that had sold, the two that most accurately reflected the size, age and expected condition (once the clean us was done) of the Raccoon Trail property sold for $790,000 and $845,000.  The other two were significantly larger (2268 sf and 2977 sf as opposed to 1770 sf), with one being on the golf course and they both sold for $1,060,000 each.  They also took between 4-5 months to sell.  The last property we looked at was on Ocean Road, a substantially better location  a stone’s throw from  the beach and with one more bedroom  but similar in overall  size, listed at $975,000 and contingent at the time we looked at the information.  It ultimately sold for $965,000.  So we listed the house at the end of April for $900,000, which at the time was more than the other properties of similar size and location had sold for but accounted for the fact that the house would be neat and clean at time of sale.

     As you know, the house initially was in a very challenging condition and could not be shown as it was.  Every room was filled to the brim with stuff and the house had not been cleaned or maintained for a very long time.  We could not put it in the MLS because we could not get in there to show it.  We all—including myself, but especially Heather and you—-worked very hard and for a long time to clear the house and get it market ready.  I know the trust spent  money getting the house market ready, but in fairness, I would guess that a large portion of that did not actually go to improvements but to clearing out the personal property and the labor costs of those who were paid to help out.   The major improvements were paint, flooring, baseboards, cleaning which were all necessary to obtain the market price we got. 

     Absolutely in no way did you, Cathy ever “refuse” to put the house on MLS.  In fact, I recall that you were somewhat frustrated by how long the clean out process was taking.  But it was a huge job and most of it fell on the shoulders  of Heather and there was only so much she could pack in a day.   We all did our best to get through this really challenging project.  

     Meanwhile, I put the word out to several of my colleagues that this property would be coming on the market for $900,000.  Several people drove by and took a look, but apparently were not impressed enough to make an offer.  I know that some potential buyers came through while the estate sale was happening but they also did not get to the point of making an offer. 

      I had a past client who was hiring an executive to come out from Indiana to work for him.  This executive has a grown child with Down’s Syndrome, so I thought that the Raccoon Trail house could be a perfect house for them as their son could walk to  Gateway House from there, etc., etc.  So I suggested  to this client of mine that his company buy this property on behalf of their new executive so that his transition to the area would be easier.  The plan was that the executive could then reimburse the company for the property….or keep renting it from the company.  So I made an appointment with Heather and brought my client over to see it.  Because he liked my plan, he made a full price, all-cash offer with an approx 30 day close in as-is condition. By then, the house was painted and the floors were installed.  However, there were many issues that came out later that ultimately needed to be addressed, like the roof, plumbing, termite fumigation,appliances, heater ductwork etc., that the buyer ultimately did have to address later after close of escrow.

      Obviously an all-cash, full-price, quick close offer was the best possible outcome for the sale of this house. So, after consulting again with the trust attorney, Cathy accepted the offer and the house went into escrow around May 15 and closed June 19 after all the personal contents had been removed.   It was my impression that Cathy always ran everything past the trust attorney first before making a decision.

      Once all the contents were removed, we put the house into the MLS as a contingent sale since we received the offer previous to putting it on MLS.  I do not believe this in any way negated a better outcome.  This buyer paid full price, as is,with an all cash deal (no qualifying for a bank loan,etc) and a quick close.  The reason we did not put into the MLS sooner is because we could not show the house in the condition it was in.  Once the house was entered in the MLS, I put a lockbox on it.   If the house were under market value—which it emphatically was not—any number of buyers could have and would have put in back up offers in case the first escrow fell out.  However, nobody did.

     Buyer then did approx $3,600 worth of termite fumigation work and the tenant (executive) moved in.  Unfortunately, from the very first week, the family had trouble with the house.  The plumbing backed up three times and the plumbing/sewer line needed significant work. The garbage disposal broke.  The washing machine leaked.  The oven temperature was off.  And the worst thing was that the neighbor behind the house went off on the wife when their little dog slipped through the broken fence and went into his yard (which also meant the back fence needed repair).  He shouted and cursed at her and kept it up every time she was in the in yard her dogs.  She is originally from Scotland and was very offended and also did not like the idea of living next door to a crazy person with a temper as her husband was constantly traveling and she was alone with her special needs son.  The only reason I know all of is this is I am the person she  called every time something went wrong with the house.  So she just could not be convinced to live there and moved out as soon as they could.

     So by October, my client decided the best thing to do was to try to sell the house as he really did not want the aggravation of being a landlord unless it was for his employee and he really did not want to have to carry an empty house.  Fortunately,  the market had improved since the previous quarter.  Statistics show that while the market in Pebble Beach remained  flat from January 2015 through June 2015, by October when I re listed the property, the total closed dollar volume sales for Pebble Beach had almost doubled ($10,992,500 in June of 2015 and $18,854,140 in October) and the median price of sold homes was up by 26% from June to October.   The market is cyclical and it is not unusual for the climate to change from quarter to quarter.  It is definitely not unusual for the real estate market to have price swings over a five month period.    So I listed the home at $1,100,000, hoping that the seller’s costs in commissions plus the carrying costs and  improvements  would  be covered.  


     I do not think it is relevant nor ethical for me to discuss the details of a transaction that the trust was not a party to.  However, just to set your mind at ease, I absolutely did not represent the buyer.  The buyer was represented by a completely different real estate agency.   Also, the buyer made an offer in a similar fashion to the first time it sold; in other words, he met our asking price before I had a chance to put in in the MLS.  So, to answer the statement by your relative that the MLS description did not give any detail of improvements, it was not necessary to put a lot of info on the description as the house was already in escrow. 

     During this time, I called Heather and left a message for her.  I wanted to discuss what had transpired and I also had a question about a major repair under the house that the new owner had to do.   I had hoped she didn’t pay for that repair as it had not been done.  But she did not return my call.

     By the way, the house on Raccoon Trail that your relative referred to as selling for $1.3 million was a 4 bedroom, 3 bath home significantly larger than your sister’s home  and property (2600 sf on a 13,000 sf lot) and it sold at the height of the market boom in 2004.  That would not have been a relevant comparable to look at 11 years later when the market had not yet nearly recovered or come back to the landmark pricing of a decade ago.

     Aside from representing the trust in trying to get the best possible outcome with the sale of the house for your sister so that she could afford the best care her money can buy, as you and Heather know, I did my best to work along side you both for months in trying to get through the personal property.  I helped with referrals for buyers for the items, helped  with recommendations for dealers who might be interested in the items for sale, showed you how to stage the sale, helped with pricing of items because of my background as a personal property appraiser, helped clean out the garage, loaned you tables for the sale, etc.    I did this without compensation  and to be helpful and supportive to your family in any way I could.  

     I hope this information will bring closure to your relative and I hope I have addressed her concerns. Everyone worked very diligently to do their very best for your sister so that she could have the care and comfort that she deserves and needs.  I was really happy to bring you such a strong offer and I stand by the facts.  Sometimes what you read on the internet does not tell the whole story and I think one should have all the facts before jumping to such serious accusations.  I hope your sister is as comfortable as she possibly can be and is receiving the full benefit of her trust in having her needs met as that is how it should be.

    If you need any further information, Cathy, please feel free to reach out.

    Best,
      Vilia   

Vilia Kakis Gilles
Sotheby's International Realty
BRE#00883948
(831)-760-7091

2015 Top 3 Producing Agent 
Top 1% Producing Agent Nationwide


-------- Original message --------
From: Sharyn Bovat <sharynbovat@icloud.com>
Date: 03/21/2016 6:16 AM (GMT-08:00)
To: jogthru <jogthru@yahoo.com>, "Kyle A. Krasa" <kyle@krasalaw.com>, Claudia <cojocar1@telus.net>, Heather Bovat <h_bov@hotmail.com>, Traci Bovat <traci.bovat@live.com>, Michael Dorris <michael.dorris@credit-suisse.com>, Michael Reyes <mike_reyes@outlook.com>
Subject: Records Show "Fishy" Transaction in reference to sale of Mom's Home. Estate can re-coup loss via action against realtor. It Starts with a formal complaint to the Real Estate Board .